Maintaining your myelin, Part 2

Continuing Part 1 with three 2024 preprint studies, starting with an investigation of neuroinflammation in high school athletes:

“Axons are long fibers conducting nerve impulses from nerve cells to synaptic ends. Like electric wires, axons are insulated by the myelin sheath produced by oligodendrocytes (ODC) in the brain or Schwann cells in the periphery. The myelin sheath is vulnerable to mechanical stresses after head injuries, as well as targets for autoimmune attack in multiple sclerosis and degeneration in various white matter diseases.

145850ce6289d06e5318d35f

It is challenging to definitively validate axonal neuroinflammation, because axonal neuroinflammation is only diagnosed at post-mortem autopsy, or wait for more than a decade to potentially witness progression to chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or white matter dementia. Advanced imaging analysis of computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging are not sensitive enough to identify such microscopic abnormalities.

We developed a sandwich immunoassay detecting dual signals of myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) and interleukin 1B (IL1B) in human plasma, [IL1B on MOG]. MOG is a transmembrane protein specifically expressed in ODC and Schwann cells membranes, and doesn’t freely exist in plasma. We found that serum from capillary blood is acceptable, and we tested control and athlete samples using only 5 mL samples. When we tested 63 control plasma samples, values were widely distributed over 2 logs, so we focused on longitudinal studies.

Damaged neurons are not easily detectable using conventional physical examinations, because the brain’s inherent adaptability allows it to compensate for localized damage by finding alternate routes. While this adaptability is advantageous, it also means that these concealed lesions can go unnoticed, potentially leading to future complications.

Elevation of [IL1B on MOG] was seen in some athletes who did not show concussion or traumatic brain injury (TBI). While the occurrence of concussion is relatively limited, potential prevalence of subconcussion or subconcussive condition is expected to be substantially higher.

If [IL1B on MOG] levels remain unchanged during this early post-concussion period (2-4 weeks), it may suggest that neuroinflammation has not been induced, potentially providing reassurance for the athletes to return to play. Conversely, if [IL1B on MOG] levels increase within this timeframe, it may indicate the need for intervention or closer monitoring. Thus, there is compelling potential for incorporating this test into concussion guidelines.”

https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-3997676/v1 “An approach for the analysis of axonal neuroinflammation by measuring dual biomarkers of oligodendrocytes and inflammatory cytokine in human plasma”


A rodent study investigated the immune system’s influence on oligodendrocyte lineage cells after TBI:

“White matter injury is thought to be a major contributor to long-term cognitive dysfunctions after TBI. This damage occurs partly due to apoptotic death of oligodendrocyte lineage cells (OLCs) after injury, triggered directly by the trauma or in response to degenerating axons.

Our data indicates that depletion of the gut microbiota after TBI impaired remyelination, reduced OLCs proliferation, and required the presence of T cells. This suggests that T cells are an important mechanistic link by which the gut microbiota modulate oligodendrocyte response and white matter recovery after TBI.

Our findings suggest that oligodendrocytes are not passive in the neuroinflammatory and degenerative environment caused by brain trauma, but instead could exert an active role in modulation of immune response.”

https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-4289147/v1 “Gut Microbiota Shape Oligodendrocyte Response after Traumatic Brain Injury”


A rodent study investigated whether oligodendrocyte precursor cells had myelination-independent roles in brain aging:

“OPCs, the source cells of myelin-forming cells in the central nervous system, have been linked to brain aging by their compromised differentiation and regeneration capability. Our results demonstrate that macroautophagy influx declines in aged OPCs, which results in the accumulation of senescent OPCs in aged brains. Senescent OPCs impair neuronal plasticity and exacerbate neurodegeneration, eventually leading to cognitive decline.

Inactivation of autophagy in OPCs exhibits a limited effect on myelin thickness but a loss of myelin in middle-aged mice. The loss of myelin observed is an adaptational change to suppressed neuronal plasticity. However, neither the number of OLs nor oligodendrogenesis is altered by inactivation of autophagy in adult OPCs.

The present study indicates that the intervention of senescent OPCs is an additional promising therapeutic strategy for aging and aging-related cognitive deficits. Autophagy regulates senescence by impairing protein turnover, mitochondrial homeostasis, oxidative stress, and maintaining senescence-associated secretory phenotype. Further investigation remains on whether autophagy in OPCs shares the exact mechanism to promote senescence as that in other types of cells.

Considering autophagy declines with aging, our study brings a novel mechanism in brain aging. Declined autophagy causes senescence of OPCs, which impairs neuronal plasticity and exacerbates neurodegeneration via CCL3/5-CCR5 signaling.”

https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-3926942/v1 “Impaired Macroautophagy in Oligodendrocyte Precursor Cells Exacerbates Aging-related Cognitive Deficits via a Senescence Associated Signaling”


PXL_20240418_104114528.MP

Maintaining your myelin, Part 1

Three papers on myelin and oligodendrocytes, starting with a 2023 review:

“Myelin is the spiral ensheathment of axons by a lipid and cholesterol-rich glial cell membrane that reduces capacitance and increases resistance of the axonal membrane. Axonal myelination speeds up nerve conduction velocity as a function of axon diameter.

While myelination proceeds rapidly after birth in the peripheral nervous system, central myelination is a spatially and temporally more regulated process. Ongoing myelination of the human brain has been documented at up to 40 years of age. This late myelination in the adult cortex is followed by exhaustion of oligodendrocyte precursor cells (OPC) with senescence and a gradual loss of myelin integrity in the aging brain.

The brain is well known for its high energy demands, specifically in gray matter areas. In white matter tracts, energy consumption is lower. Myelination poses a unique challenge for axonal energy generation where myelin sheaths cover more than 95% of the axonal surface areas.

Oligodendrocytes help support axonal integrity. Oligodendrocytes survive well in the absence of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation, and without signs of myelin loss, cell death, neurodegeneration or secondary inflammation.

Glycolysis products of oligodendroglial origin are readily metabolized in axonal mitochondria. Oligodendroglial metabolic support is critical for larger and faster-spiking myelinated axons that also have a higher density of mitochondria. An essential requirement for the direct transfer of energy-rich metabolites from oligodendrocytes to the myelinated axonal compartment is ‘myelinic channels’ within the myelin sheath.

Interactions of oligodendrocytes and myelin with the underlying axon are complex and exceed the transfer of energy-rich metabolites. Continuous turnover of myelin membranes by lipid degradation and fatty acid beta-oxidation in mitochondria and peroxisomes leads to recycling of acetate residues by fatty acid synthesis and membrane biogenesis.

1-s2.0-S0959438823001071-gr2_lrg

In human multiple sclerosis (MS) and its animal model myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein-experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (MOG-EAE), acute inflammatory demyelination is followed by axonal degeneration in lesion sites that is mechanistically not fully understood. It is widely thought that demyelination and the lack of an axon-protective myelin sheath in the presence of numerous inflammatory mediators are the main causes of axon loss.

But unprotected axons improve rather than worsen the overall clinical phenotype of EAE mice which exhibited the same degree of autoimmunity. Thus, ‘bad myelin is worse than no myelin’ because MS-relevant myelin injuries perturb the integrity of myelinic channels and metabolic support.

Dysfunctional or injured oligodendrocytes that do not allow for compensation by any other cell types turn the affected myelin ensheathment into a burden of the underlying axonal energy metabolism, which causes irreversible axon loss. Any loss of myelin integrity, as seen acutely in demyelinating disorders or more gradually in the aging brain, becomes a risk factor for irreversible neurodegeneration.”

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959438823001071 “Expanding the function of oligodendrocytes to brain energy metabolism”


A 2024 review focused on myelin and oligodendrocyte plasticity:

“This review summarizes our current understanding of how myelin is generated, how its function is dynamically regulated, and how oligodendrocytes support the long-term integrity of myelinated axons.

Apart from its unique ultrastructure, there are several other exceptional features of myelin. One is certainly its molecular composition. Another is its extraordinary stability. This was compellingly illustrated when 5000-year-old myelin with almost intact ultrastructure was dissected from a Tyrolean Ice Man.

Myelin is a stable system in contrast to most membranes. However, myelin is compartmentalized into structurally and biochemically distinct domains. Noncompacted regions are much more dynamic and metabolically active than tightly compacted regions that lack direct access to the membrane trafficking machinery of oligodendrocytes.

The underlying molecular basis for stability of myelin is likely its lipid composition with high levels of saturated, long chain fatty acids, together with an enrichment of glycosphingolipids (∼20% molar percentage of total lipids) and cholesterol (∼40% of molar percentage of total lipids). In addition, myelin comprises a high proportion of plasmalogens (ether lipids) with saturated long-chain fatty acids. In fact, ∼20% of the fatty acids in myelin have hydrocarbon chains longer than 18 carbon atoms (∼1% in the gray matter) and only ∼6% of the fatty acids are polyunsaturated (∼20% in gray matter).

With maturation of oligodendrocytes, the plasma membrane undergoes major transformations of its structure. Whereas OPCs are covered by a dense layer of large and negatively charged self-repulsive oligosaccharides, compacted myelin of fully matured oligodendrocytes lacks most of these glycoprotein and complex glycolipids.

Schematic depiction of an oligodendrocyte that takes up blood-derived glucose and delivers glycolysis products (pyruvate/lactate) via monocarboxylate transporters (MCT1 and MCT2) to myelinated axons. Oligodendrocytes and myelin membranes are also coupled by gap junctions to astrocytes, and thus indirectly to the blood–brain barrier.

oligodendrocyte

Adaptive myelination refers to dynamic events in oligodendroglia driven by extrinsic factors such as experience or neuronal activity, which subsequently induces changes in circuit structure and function. Understanding how these adaptive changes in neuron-oligodendroglia interactions impact brain function remains a pressing question for the field.

Transient social isolation during adulthood results in chromatin and myelin changes, but does not induce consequent behavioral alterations. When mice undergo a social isolation paradigm during early life development, they similarly exhibit deficits in prefrontal cortex function and myelination, but these deficiencies do not recover with social reintroduction. This implicates a critical period for social deprivation effects on myelin dynamics. Experience-dependent changes in myelin dynamics may depend on not only the age, brain region, and cell type studied, but also the specific myelin structural change assessed.

Local synaptic neurotransmitter release along an axon not only affects the number of OPCs and oligodendrocytes associated with that axon and local synthesis of myelin proteins, but also drives preferential selection of active axons for myelination over the ensheathment of electrically silenced neighboring axons. Neuronal activity–induced plasticity may preferentially impact brain regions that remain incompletely myelinated compared to more fully myelinated tracts.

Whereas the myelin sheath has been regarded for a long time as an inert insulating structure, it has now become clear that myelin is metabolically active with cytoplasmic-rich pathways, myelinic channels, for movement of macromolecules into the periaxonal space. The myelin sheath and its subjacent axon need to be regarded as one functional unit, which are not only morphological but also metabolically coupled.”

https://cshperspectives.cshlp.org/content/early/2024/04/15/cshperspect.a041359 “Oligodendrocytes: Myelination, Plasticity, and Axonal Support” (not freely available) Thanks to Dr. Klaus-Armin Nave for providing a copy.


A 2024 rodent study investigated oligodendrocyte precursor cell transcriptional and epigenetic changes:

“We used single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq), single-cell ATAC sequencing (scATAC-seq), and single-cell spatial transcriptomics to characterize murine cortical OPCs throughout postnatal life. One group (active, or actOPCs) is metabolically active and enriched in white matter. The second (homeostatic, or hOPCs) is less active, enriched in gray matter, and predicted to derive from actOPCs. Relative to developing OPCs, both actOPCs and hOPCs are less active metabolically and have less open chromatin.

In adulthood, these two groups are transcriptionally but not epigenetically distinct, indicating that they may represent different states of the same OPC population. If that is the case, then one model is that the parenchymal environment maintains adult OPCs within an hOPC state, whereas those OPCs recruited into white matter or exposed to demyelinated axons may transition toward an actOPC state in preparation for making new oligodendrocytes. We do not yet know the functional ramifications of these differences, but this finding has clear implications for the development of therapeutic strategies for adult remyelination.

opcs

Another finding is that developing but not adult actOPC chromatin is preferentially open for binding motifs associated with neural stem cells, transit-amplifying precursors, and neurogenesis. Although this may simply reflect their origin as the immediate progeny of neonatal neural precursor cells, it may also explain why developing but not adult OPCs have the capacity to make neurons in culture.

If we could, at least in part, reverse the global chromatin shutdown that occurs between development and adulthood, then perhaps adult OPCs may reacquire the ability to make neurons or become better able to generate new oligodendrocytes for remyelination.”

https://www.cell.com/stem-cell-reports/fulltext/S2213-6711(24)00077-8 “Single-cell approaches define two groups of mammalian oligodendrocyte precursor cells and their evolution over developmental time”

Continued in Part 2.


PXL_20240414_103442372

A good activity for bad weather days

A free educational series recorded in 2021-2022 available at https://drgoodenowe.com/dr-goodenowes-educational-seminars/ takes the viewer through underlying research and principles of Dr. Goodenowe’s approach to health. It’s advertised as lasting four hours, but took me two days to view.

The series’ discussions and references are background material to better understand later presentations and interviews. Points of interest included:

  • Seminar B100 shows that the metabolomic profile of people who regularly eat broccoli is different than others.
  • B109 clarifies how peroxisomal function is improved through resistance exercise and intermittent fasting.
  • C103 and C104 show how plasmalogens act against neurodegeneration (Parkinson’s disease and multiple sclerosis).

Texts below videos are additional information, not transcripts. C101 text is historically informative.


The B200 ProdromeScan tutorial will take more study. But unlike Labcorp tests, ordering a ProdromeScan requires using a practitioner in Dr. Goodenowe’s network.

I sent the following to Prodrome customer service earlier this month:

Please add me to your approved list for ProdromeScan.

Customer service replied:

“We only add health professionals to an approved list, not individuals.”

I responded:

Good morning. I looked at the websites of doctors who are associated with Dr. Goodenowe who are near me. All of them are too compromised for me to establish a doctor / patient relationship. But I’m glad they left up their blog posts from earlier this decade so I could see who they really were before I reached out to them.

I request an exception to the policy.

Customer service replied:

“There is no exception that can be made to this policy. You need to be a patient of a certified practitioner.”

I’ll escalate my request before my 90-day trial of Prodrome Glia and Neuro products ends so I can get an appropriate metabolomic status. Right now, I won’t involve someone I can’t trust just to know my ProdromeScan information that’s additional to next week’s Labcorp tests.

My treatment-result metabolomic data is probably not mature today on Day 29 of ProdromeGlia and ProdromeNeuro supplementation, resistance exercise, and intermittent fasting. I otherwise wouldn’t have experienced these two events:


I have a quibble with the series’ recommendations for taking N-acetyl cysteine. Relevant views and research:

Switch on your Nrf2 signaling pathway pointed out:

“We use NAC in the lab all the time because it stops an Nrf2 activation. So that weak pro-oxidant signal that activates Nrf2, you switch it off by giving a dose of NAC. It’s a potent antioxidant in that right, but it’s blocking signalling. And that’s what I don’t like about its broad use.”

If someone bombs themself everyday with antioxidants, they’re doing nothing to improve training of their endogenous systems’ defensive functions. What happens when they stop bombing? One example was a 2022 human study that found GlyNAC-induced improvements dissolved back to baseline after supplements stopped.

Also, Precondition your defenses with broccoli sprouts highlighted NAC’s deleterious effects on autophagy and lysosome functions:

“TFEB activity is required for sulforaphane (SFN)-induced protection against both acute oxidant bursts and chronic oxidative stress. SFN-induced TFEB nuclear accumulation was completely blocked by pretreatment of cells by N-acetyl-cysteine (NAC), or by other commonly used antioxidants. NAC also blocked SFN-induced mRNA expression of TFEB target genes, as well as SFN-induced autophagosome formation.”

If a secondary goal of taking NAC per is also necessary for the formation of glutathione, taurine can do that without an antioxidant bomb. Taurine supplementation will free up cysteine to do things other than synthesize taurine, like synthesize glutathione.


PXL_20231123_194849211.MP

Brain restoration with plasmalogens

In this 2023 presentation for a professional audience, Dr. Dayan Goodenowe showed an example of what could be done (in the form of what he personally did at ages 53-54) to restore and augment brain structure and function over a 17-month period by taking plasmalogens and supporting supplements:

https://drgoodenowe.com/recording-of-dr-goodenowes-presentation-from-the-peptide-world-congress-2023-is-now-available/

Follow the video along with its interactive transcript. Restorative / augmentative supplements included:

1. Nutritional Supplementation Strategy

Forms of MRI used to document brain structure and function changes were:

2. Advanced MRI Technologies

Brain volume decreases are the rule for humans beginning at age 40. Dr. Goodenowe documented brain volume increases, which aren’t supposed to happen, but did per the below slide of overall results:

3. Reversing Brain Shrinkage

“From a global cortical volume and thickness perspective, 17 months of high-dose plasmalogens reversed ~15 years of predicted brain deterioration.”


Specific increased adaptations in brain measurements over 17 months included:

  1. Cortical thickness .07/2.51 = +3%.
  2. White matter microstructure fractional anisotropy +8%.
  3. Nucleus accumbens volume +30%.
  4. Dopaminergic striatal terminal fields’ volume +18%.
  5. Cholinergic cortical terminal fields’ volume +10%.
  6. Occipital cortex volume +10%.
  7. Optic chiasm volume +225%.
  8. Nucleus basalis connectivity.
  9. Neurovascular coupling signal controlled by noradrenaline integrity.
  10. Amygdala volume +4% and its connectivity to the insula, indicating ongoing anxiety and emotional stress response.
  11. Parahippocampus volume +7%.
  12. Hippocampus fractional anisotropy +5%.

No changes:

  1. Amygdala connectivity to the ventral lateral prefrontal cortex, the same part of the brain that relates to placebo effect.
  2. Hippocampus connectivity.

Decreased adaptations in brain measurements included:

  1. White matter microstructure radial diffusivity -10%.
  2. Amygdala connectivity to the anterior cingulate cortex to suppress / ignore / deny anxiety response.
  3. Amygdala connectivity to the dorsal lateral prefrontal cortex.
  4. Entorhinal cortex volume -14%.
  5. Hippocampus volume -6%.
  6. Hippocampus mean diffusivity (white matter improved, with more and tighter myelin) -4%.

The other half of this video was a lively and wide-ranging Q&A session.


The referenced 2023 study of 653 adults followed over ten years showed what brain deterioration could be expected with no interventions. Consider these annual volume decrease rates to be a sample of a control group:

etable 3

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2806488 “Characterization of Brain Volume Changes in Aging Individuals With Normal Cognition Using Serial Magnetic Resonance Imaging”

Also see a different population’s brain shrinkage data in Prevent your brain from shrinking.


The daily plasmalogen precursor doses Dr. Goodenowe took were equivalent to 100 mg softgel/kg, double the maximum dose of 50 mg softgel/kg provided during the 2022 clinical trial of cognitively impaired old people referenced in Plasmalogens Parts 1, 2, and 3.

He mentions taking 5 ml in the morning and 5 ml at night because he used the Prodrome oil products. 1 ml of a Prodrome oil plasmalogen precursor product equals 900 mg of their softgel product.


“My brain is trying to minimize long-term effects of pain/stress by suppressing my memory of it. But this can only go on for so long before it becomes an entrenched state.

I have solved the sustenance side of the equation. I need to work harder to solve the environmental side.”

While I agree that we each have a responsibility to ourselves to create an environment that’s conducive to our health, the above phenomenon isn’t necessarily resolvable by changing an individual’s current environment. My understanding is that long-term effects of pain, stress, and related human experiences are usually symptoms of causes that started much earlier in our lives.

Adjusting one’s present environment may have immediate results, but probably won’t have much therapeutic impact on long-term issues. Early life memories and experiences are where we have to gradually go in order to stop being driven by what happened back then.

See Dr. Arthur Janov’s Primal Therapy for its principles and explanations. I started Primal Therapy at a similar age, 53, and continued for three years.

Plasmalogens, Part 1

The person who knows the most about this subject is Dayan Goodenowe, PhD. Some recent publications include:

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcell.2022.864842/full “Targeted Plasmalogen Supplementation: Effects on Blood Plasmalogens, Oxidative Stress Biomarkers, Cognition, and Mobility in Cognitively Impaired Persons”

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcell.2022.866156/full “Brain ethanolamine phospholipids, neuropathology and cognition: A comparative post-mortem analysis of structurally specific plasmalogen and phosphatidyl species”

plasmalogens and cognition


A sample of links freely available at https://drgoodenowe.com/.

1. Presentations to professional groups. Have your mouse ready to click the pause button.

https://drgoodenowe.com/dr-goodenowe-presents-at-the-iagg2023-in-yokohama-japan/ “A rare children’s disease that may be the key to reversing neurological decline in aging”

Includes videos of a treatment’s effects on a child.

https://neomarkgroup.wistia.com/medias/0qln0wy93t “The most influential biomarkers for aging and disease”

Despite the title, a considerable number of studies were presented on prenatal, infant, and early childhood development. He misspoke a few times, so read the slides.

Phenotype is reality. Genotype is possibility. Communications links between different fields are very poorly connected in science.

Peroxisomes are islands. They don’t have DNA like your mitochondria do. Peroxisomal transport issues are important things to understand.

All aging-related cross-sectional analyses are on the rate of decline. You’re declining from a previous well state. Age-matched controls are the most ridiculous thing to do.”


2. I’ll highlight the longest of several interviews because there was plenty of room to expand on points. Maybe the best detailed explanations came as responses to that interviewer challenging with contrasting AD, traumatic brain injury, and cholesterol paradigms. Its transcript is more accurate than a usual YouTube interpretation, but there are still mistakes such as “fossil lipid” vs. phospholipid.

https://www.betterhealthguy.com/episode186 “Plasmalogens with Dr. Dayan Goodenowe, PhD”

“Science is how do you push things to its failure, until you can’t fail it again. We’ve lost that. It’s become more hypothesis proving.

Plasmalogens levels go up for a different reason than people think. The reason why it peaks in our 40s and 50s is because we’ve been myelinating. The white matter of our brain is still increasing. It’s not because we’re making more plasmalogens. It’s because the lake, the reservoir, gets full. What you’re measuring in blood is overflow from the lake. The lower plasmalogens start trickling down in your blood, the bigger drain that’s occurring on that system.

Low plasmalogens don’t just predict dementia in the elderly population. It predicts the rate of decline of that dementia. It predicts the rate of death.

The biggest drivers of plasmalogen manufacturing and the biggest reasons why they decrease with age, or in other circumstances is two things. One, the failure to maintain a fasting state of the human body. The second one is muscle atrophy.

Amyloid has absolutely nothing to do with Alzheimer’s, or dementia. It’s just a bystander on the road watching an accident happen.

Age-related cognitive decline is clearly where plasmalogens have the greatest impact. You’re always going to have mixed pathologies in the brain.

Nutritional availability of plasmalogens is virtually non-existent. As soon as they hit the hydrochloric acid of your stomach, they’re gone. They don’t make it past the stomach, or the upper intestine.”


I came across Dr. Goodenowe’s work last month from clicking a comment on this blog that linked back to her blog. Always be curious.

Continued in Part 2.

Beneficial dietary erucic acid?

A 2022 review to follow up Caution on broccoli seed erucic acid content?:

“Erucic acid is found to cause cardiac lipidosis in young animals, yet direct evidence of cardiac injury does not exist for young humans. Concerns about erucic acid safety and cardiotoxicity have been published in the press which are based on scientific reports in the 1970s that erucic acid disrupted oxidative phosphorylation and lead to accumulation of lipids in rat cardiac tissue.

Spanish toxic oil syndrome was a major concern, leading to questions about erucic acid cardiotoxicity. Yet it was found that not rapeseed oil per se, rather its carcinogen anilin-dye refined derivative caused cardiotoxicity.

Later, it was understood that reduced ATP production with erucic acid treatment was due to unapt isolation of rat cardiac mitochondria and lipid accumulation that was unique to rats that inherently harbour a low β-oxidative peroxisomal activity and tissue-specific metabolism of erucic acid. Similar structural or metabolic perturbations and tissue injuries were not encountered in monkeys, humans, and pigs.

Potential mechanisms regarding antineoplastic effects of erucic acid in brain tumors:

erucic acid

In children (0 to 14 years), medulloblastomas accounted for less than 10% of brain neoplasias in China, African countries, and Ireland. The ratio was in the range 20%–29% in Brazil, Argentina, Thailand, Korea and Poland, the proportion was 30% in Ecuador, 31% in Taiwan and Jordan.

In adults, the ratio of brain neoplasias diagnosed as glioblastoma was:

  • Below 10% only in China;
  • In the range 10%–29% in India, Thailand, Malaysia, Nigeria, Algeria, Malta, Costa Rica, Ecuador, and the Russian Federation;
  • In the range 30%–49% in some South American countries, Singapore, Taiwan, Japan, Korea, Turkey, Denmark, Iceland, Italy, and Spain among others; and
  • In the range 50%–70% in North America, Puerto Rico, Martinique, Israel, Cyprus, Jordan, Kuwait, and in Oceania.

The low ratio of medulloblastomas in children and of glioblastomas in adult Chinese population cannot be easily attributed to a single genetic and nurture pattern. Very likely, many complex factors interact to explain this difference regarding the Chinese population.

Several hypotheses can be put forward to illuminate the cause of reduced ratios of high grade brain tumors in Chinese which would be of benefit for global reduction and prevention of brain tumors. Erucic acid is very highly consumed in the Chinese diet, and 8-fold higher erucic acid levels exist in Chinese women’s milk in comparison to many other countries.

We hypothesized that dietary erucic acid may be – at least among many factors – associated with reduced ratios of high grade brain tumors in Chinese. If epidemiological and animal studies would prove such an association, an effective, cheap, and relatively non-toxic dietary supplementary strategy may be employed to prevent brain tumors at erucic acid doses lower than those associated with any cardiotoxic effects.”

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11011-022-01022-4 “Could dietary erucic acid lower risk of brain tumors? An epidemiological look to Chinese population with implications for prevention and treatment” (not freely available) Thanks to Dr. Meric Altinoz for providing a copy.


PXL_20220718_093918636

Young gut, young eyes

I’ll highlight this 2022 rodent study findings of effects on eye health:

“We tested the hypothesis that manipulating intestinal microbiota influences development of major comorbidities associated with aging and, in particular, inflammation affecting the brain and retina. Using fecal microbiota transplantation, we exchanged intestinal microbiota of young (3 months), old (18 months), and aged (24 months) mice.

Transfer of aged donor microbiota into young mice accelerates age-associated central nervous system inflammation, retinal inflammation, and cytokine signaling. It promotes loss of key functional protein in the eye, effects which are coincident with increased intestinal barrier permeability.

These detrimental effects can be reversed by transfer of young donor microbiota.

young and aged fmt

We provide the first direct evidence that aged intestinal microbiota drives retinal inflammation, and regulates expression of the functional visual protein RPE65. RPE65 is vital for maintaining normal photoceptor function via trans-retinol conversion. Mutations or loss of function are associated with retinitis pigmentosa, and are implicated in age-related macular degeneration.

Our finding that age-associated decline in host retinal RPE65 expression is induced by an aged donor microbiota, and conversely is rescued by young donor microbiota transfer, suggests age-associated gut microbiota functions or products regulate visual function.”

https://microbiomejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40168-022-01243-w “Fecal microbiota transfer between young and aged mice reverses hallmarks of the aging gut, eye, and brain”


PXL_20220517_190954606

Human agency vs. brain dysfunction

This 2021 human study used epigenetic clock technology to assess chronic inflammation as a driver of cognitive decline through its effects on brain structure:

“An epigenetic measure of C-reactive protein (DNAm CRP) was assembled for each participant. We found that higher inflammatory burden, indexed by DNAm CRP scores, associated with poor cognitive and neuroimaging brain health outcomes.

inflammation vs cognitive ability

DNAm CRP exhibited significantly larger associations with brain structural MRI metrics (including global grey and white matter atrophy, poorer white matter microstructure, and increased white matter hyperintensity burden) than serum CRP. Given that the 7 CpGs which make up DNAm CRP score reside in inflammation and vascular-related genes, these DNAm CRP-brain MRI associations may be capturing the impact of upstream inflammatory activity above and beyond that of serum CRP levels.

Our results indicate that some cognitive domains (processing speed) may be more mediated by brain structural consequences of chronic inflammation than others (verbal memory, visuospatial ability).

Our results add to the evidence base that DNAm-based predictors of inflammation may act as a quantifiable archive of longitudinal effects of these exposures – and other unaccounted for health and genetic profiles – that serum CRP levels fail to capture. By utilising an epigenetic inflammation measure, which integrates information from multiple immune-related CpG sites, we may provide a more reliable measure of chronic inflammation and thus a more comprehensive overview of consequences of chronic inflammation on brain structure and function.”

https://n.neurology.org/content/early/2021/11/17/WNL.0000000000012997.long “DNA Methylation and Protein Markers of Chronic Inflammation and Their Associations With Brain and Cognitive Aging”


These researchers essentially negated many of their findings by acknowledging:

“Although we endeavoured to remove participants with cognition-related pathology, these were screened via self-reported diagnoses, and we may be missing undiagnosed or subclinical incident neurodegenerative pathology.”

It wasn’t sufficient to claim in the Abstract section “Participants (N = 521) were cognitively normal, around 73 years of age” then include in the Discussion section a one-sentence limitation of relying on self-reports. Everyone defends themself against current and past realities and experiences.

Hard to imagine that objective measures such as the three comprising cognitive ability weren’t better screens. But then too many 73-year-old subjects may not have been “cognitively normal” and this study wouldn’t be adequately powered?

Can humans counteract inflammation? Non-communicable diseases? Smoking? Immune system degradation? Yes. No personal-agency actions were mentioned.

Also note this study’s social norming. The above-pictured 30-year-old female was busy at work, and subsequently hoisted a cat instead of a child in later years.

Take responsibility for your own one precious life.

PXL_20211118_114858264

The amino acid ergothioneine

A trio of papers on ergothioneine starts with a 2019 human study. 3,236 people without cardiovascular disease and diabetes mellitus ages 57.4 ± 6.0 were measured for 112 metabolites, then followed-up after 20+ years:

“We identified that higher ergothioneine was an independent marker of lower risk of cardiometabolic disease and mortality, which potentially can be induced by a specific healthy dietary intake.

overall mortality and ergothioneine

Ergothioneine exists in many dietary sources and has especially high levels in mushrooms, tempeh, and garlic. Ergothioneine has previously been associated with a higher intake of vegetables, seafood and with a lower intake of solid fats and added sugar as well as associated with healthy food patterns.”

https://heart.bmj.com/content/106/9/691 “Ergothioneine is associated with reduced mortality and decreased risk of cardiovascular disease”


I came across this study by its citation in a 2021 review:

“The body has evolved to rely on highly abundant low molecular weight thiols such as glutathione to maintain redox homeostasis but also play other important roles including xenobiotic detoxification and signalling. Some of these thiols may also be derived from diet, such as the trimethyl-betaine derivative of histidine, ergothioneine (ET).

image description

ET can be found in most (if not all) tissues, with differential rates of accumulation, owing to differing expression of the transporter. High expression of the transporter, and hence high levels of ET, is observed in certain cells (e.g. blood cells, bone marrow, ocular tissues, brain) that are likely predisposed to oxidative stress, although other tissues can accumulate high levels of ET with sustained administration. This has been suggested to be an adaptive physiological response to elevate ET in the damaged tissue and thereby limit further injury.”

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2213231721000161 “Ergothioneine, recent developments”


The coauthors of this review were also coauthors of a 2018 review:

“Ergothioneine is avidly taken up from the diet by humans and other animals through a transporter, OCTN1. Ergothioneine is not rapidly metabolised, or excreted in urine, and has powerful antioxidant and cytoprotective properties.

ergothioneine in foods

Effects of dietary ET supplementation on oxidative damage in young healthy adults found a trend to a decrease in oxidative damage, as detected in plasma and urine using several established biomarkers of oxidative damage, but no major decreases. This could arguably be a useful property of ET: not interfering with important roles of ROS/RNS in healthy tissues, but coming into play when oxidative damage becomes excessive due to tissue injury, toxin exposure or disease, and ET is then accumulated.”

https://febs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/1873-3468.13123 “Ergothioneine – a diet-derived antioxidant with therapeutic potential”


I’m upping a half-pound of mushrooms every day to 3/4 lb. (340 g). Don’t think I could eat more garlic than the current six cloves.

PXL_20210606_095517049

I came across this subject in today’s video:

Our brains are shaped by our early environments

This 2019 McGill paper reviewed human and animal studies on brain-shaping influences from the fetal period through childhood:

“In neonates, regions of the methylome that are highly variable across individuals are explained by the genotype alone in 25 percent of cases. The best explanation for 75 percent of variably methylated regions is the interaction of genotype with different in utero environments.

A meta-analysis including 45,821 individuals with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and 9,207,363 controls suggests that conditions such as preeclampsia, Apgar score lower than 7 at 5 minutes, breech/transverse presentations, and prolapsed/nuchal cord – all of which involve some sort of poor oxygenation during delivery – are significantly associated with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. The dopaminergic system seems to be one of the brain systems most affected by perinatal hypoxia-ischemia.

Exposure to childhood trauma activates the stress response systems and dysregulates serotonin transmission that can adversely impact brain development. Smaller cerebral, cerebellar, prefrontal cortex, and corpus callosum volumes were reported in maltreated young people as well as reduced hippocampal activity.

Environmental enrichment has a series of beneficial effects associated with neuroplasticity mechanisms, increasing hippocampal volume, and enhancing dorsal dentate gyrus-specific differences in gene expression. Environmental enrichment after prenatal stress decreases depressive-like behaviors and fear, and improves cognitive deficits.”


The reviewers presented strong evidence until the Possible Factors for Reversibility section, which ended with the assertion:

“All these positive environmental experiences mentioned in this section could counterbalance the detrimental effects of early life adversities, making individuals resilient to brain alterations and development of later psychopathology.”

The review’s penultimate sentence recognized that research is seldom done on direct treatments of causes:

“The cross-sectional nature of most epigenetic studies and the tissue specificity of the epigenetic changes are still challenges.”

Cross-sectional studies won’t provide definitive data on cause-and-effect relationships.

The question yet to be examined is: How can humans best address these early-life causes to ameliorate their lifelong effects?

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/dmcn.14182 “Early environmental influences on the development of children’s brain structure and function” (not freely available)

Epigenetic causes of sexual orientation and handedness?

This 2018 Austrian human study subject was various associations of prenatal testosterone levels to fetal development:

“The available evidence suggests, albeit not conclusively, that prenatal testosterone levels may be one cause for the association of sexual orientation with handedness. Associations among women were consistent with predictions of the Geschwind–Galaburda theory (GGT), whereas those among men were consistent with predictions of the callosal hypothesis. However, research on the associations between sexual orientation and handedness appears to be compromised by various methodological and interpretational problems which need to be overcome to arrive at a clearer picture.

The GGT posits that high prenatal testosterone levels cause a delay in the fetal development of the left cerebral hemisphere which results in a right-hemisphere dominance and hence in a tendency for left-handedness. According to the GGT, high prenatal testosterone levels entail not only a masculinization of the female fetus, but also a feminization of the male fetus (contrary to neurohormonal theory). Overall, the male fetus is subjected to higher levels of intrauterine testosterone than the female fetus. The GGT is thus consistent with the higher prevalence of left-handedness among men than among women.

The callosal hypothesis applies to men only and assumes, in line with neurohormonal theory, that low prenatal testosterone levels are associated with later homosexuality. According to the CH, high prenatal testosterone enhances processes of cerebral lateralization through mechanisms of axonal pruning, thereby resulting in stronger left-hemisphere dominance and a smaller corpus callosum. Consistent with this, women have a larger corpus callosum than men.”


The study’s Limitations section included the following:

  1. “Limitations of the current study pertain to the self-report nature of our data. Behavioral data may provide differing results from those obtained here.
  2. Assessment of sexual orientation relied on a single-item measure. Utilization of rating scales (e.g., the Kinsey Sexual Orientation Scale) or of multi-item scales, and assessing different components of sexual orientation, would have allowed for a more fine-grained analysis and for a cross-validation of sexual orientation ratings with sexual attraction.
  3. Albeit both our samples were large, the proportions of bisexual and homosexual individuals were, expectedly, only small, as were effects of lateral preferences. Thus, in analysis we could not differentiate bisexual from homosexual individuals. Bisexual and homosexual individuals may differ with regard to the distribution of lateral preferences.
  4. Some effect tests in this study have been underpowered. Independent replications with even larger samples are still needed.”

The largest unstated limitation was no fetal measurements. When a fetus’ epigenetic responses and adaptations aren’t considered, not only can the two competing hypotheses not be adequately compared, but causes for the studied phenotypic programming and other later-life effects will also be missed.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-018-1346-9 “Associations of Bisexuality and Homosexuality with Handedness and Footedness: A Latent Variable Analysis Approach”

Are there epigenetic causes for sexual orientation and gender identity?

This US 2018 review lead author was a gynecologic oncologist in private practice:

“Sexual orientation is biologically conferred in the first trimester of pregnancy. Gender identity is biologically conferred during the middle trimester of pregnancy.

Since the genitals differentiate in the first trimester, and the brain becomes imprinted in the latter half of gestation, it is possible for the fetal brain to be imprinted differently than the genitals. As children mature, this innate imprinting expresses as genital anatomy, gender identity, sexual orientation and other physiologic capabilities and natural preferences along a continuum, between masculine and feminine.

The evidence shows that both orientation and identity are biologic features that co-vary with a very large number of other biologic sexually dimorphic traits.”


1. A fetus’ development is influenced by survival reactions to their environment. Although fetal and placental responses to environmental stressors are relevant to sexual orientation and gender identity, the reviewers didn’t explore the subject.

2. Epigenetic adaptations to the prenatal environment involving microRNA were mentioned in a small subsection. But the reviewers didn’t cite relevant studies involving DNA methylation, chromatin and histone modifications for epigenetic causes of and effects on sexual orientation and gender identity.

3. The reviewers included a half-dozen anecdotal quotations from personal correspondence that promoted their narrative. These impressed as appeals to authority rather than evidence for scientific understanding of the subject.

It was insufficient for the review to note “a continuum between masculine and feminine” without also exploring evidence for an individual’s placement on the continuum. The question of possible epigenetic causes for sexual orientation and gender identity remains.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009082581731510X “Biological origins of sexual orientation and gender identity: Impact on health” (not freely available)

Parental lying thwarted both their children and researchers

This 2017 German human study explored the relationship between birth stress and handedness. The authors summarized previous research which, among other points, estimated epigenetic contributions to handedness as great as 75%.

The research hypothesis itself was worthwhile based on the prior studies cited and elsewhere such as Group statistics don’t necessarily describe an individual. But the study hit a snag in its reliance on the sixty participants (average age 24) completing, with the assistance of their parents and medical records, a 24-item questionnaire of maternal health problems during pregnancy, substance use during pregnancy, and birth complications.

It’s extremely unlikely that the sixty subjects provided accurate information. For example:

  • Only one of the subjects reported maternal alcohol use during pregnancy. An expected number would have been twenty-six!
  • None of the subjects reported maternal mental illness during pregnancy. An expected number would have been at least seven!

I’d guess that the subjects’ parents willingly misled their children about facts of their child’s important earliest development periods. It’s my view that parental lies and omissions are not only unethical to the children, but also, whenever the lies and omissions became recognized, they potentially diminish or destroy the society among family members.

As mentioned on the Welcome page, lies and omissions ruin the standard scientific methodology of surveying parents and caregivers. The absence of reliable evidence made it impossible for the current study’s researchers to determine causes of epigenetic effects still present in the subjects’ lives.

Parental lies and omissions also diminish or destroy the society between the sources of information – the research subjects – and the users of the information. Such lies and omissions adversely affect anyone who values evidence-based research.

http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1357650X.2017.1377726 “DNA methylation in candidate genes for handedness predicts handedness direction” (not freely available)

Epigenetic stress effects in preterm infants

This 2017 Italian review selected 9 human studies on the epigenetic effects of:

“One of the major adverse events in human development. Preterm infants are hospitalized in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit where they are exposed to life-saving yet pain-inducing procedures and to protective care.”

Highlights of the referenced studies included:

  • “Early exposure to adverse events during the third trimester of pregnancy is capable to alter the epigenetic status of imprinted and placenta-related genes which have relevant implications for fetal development and preterm infants’ HPA [hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal] stress reactivity during infancy.”
  • “There was an association between DNAm [DNA methylation] and white matter tract tissue integrity and shape inferred from dMRI [diffusion MRI], suggesting that epigenetic variation may contribute to the cerebral phenotype of preterm birth.”

Limitations of the referenced studies included:

  • “A multiple sampling design that includes parental samples, placental tissue, cord blood and extends across the life-course would be required to investigate the relative contributions of in utero and postnatal exposures to changes in DNAm, and the extent to which preterm birth leaves a legacy on the methylome.”
  • Saliva, blood, and other tissues’ DNA methylation may not produce valid links to brain tissue DNA methylation of the same gene, which may hamper conclusive inferences about behavior, etc.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0149763417302117 “Preterm Behavioral Epigenetics: A systematic review” (not freely available)

http://www.nature.com/tp/journal/v6/n1/full/tp2015210a.html “Epigenomic profiling of preterm infants reveals DNA methylation differences at sites associated with neural function” (one of the studies selected, quoted above)

The effects of imposing helplessness

This 2016 New York rodent study found:

“By using unbiased and whole-brain imaging techniques, we uncover a number of cortical and subcortical brain structures that have lower activity in the animals showing helplessness than in those showing resilience following the LH [learned helplessness] procedure. We also identified the LC [locus coeruleus] as the sole subcortical area that had enhanced activity in helpless animals compared with resilient ones.

Some of the brain areas identified in this study – such as areas in the mPFC [medial prefrontal cortex], hippocampus, and amygdala – have been previously implicated in clinical depression or depression-like behavior in animal models. We also identified novel brain regions previously not associated with helplessness. For example, the OT [olfactory tubercle], an area involved in odor processing as well as high cognitive functions including reward processing, and the Edinger–Westphal nucleus containing centrally projecting neurons implicated in stress adaptation.

The brains of helpless animals are locked in a highly stereotypic pathological state.”

Concerning the study’s young adult male subjects:

“To achieve a subsequent detection of neuronal activity related to distinct behavioral responses, we used the c-fosGFP transgenic mice expressing c-FosGFP under the control of a c-fos promoter. The expression of the c-fosGFP transgene has been previously validated to faithfully represent endogenous c-fos expression.

Similar to wild-type mice, approximately 22% (32 of 144) of the c-fosGFP mice showed helplessness.”

The final sentence of the Introduction section:

“Our study..supports the view that defining neuronal circuits underlying stress-induced depression-like behavior in animal models can help identify new targets for the treatment of depression.”


Helplessness is both a learned behavior and a cumulative set of experiences during every human’s early life. Therapeutic approaches to detrimental effects of helplessness can be different with humans than with rodents in that we can address causes.

The researchers categorized activity in brain circuits as causal in the Discussion section:

“Future studies aimed at manipulating these identified neural changes are required for determining whether they are causally related to the expression of helplessness or resilience.”

Studying whether or not activity in brain circuits induces helplessness in rodents may not inform us about causes of helplessness in humans. Our experiences are often the ultimate causes of helplessness effects. Many of our experiential “neural changes” are only effects, as demonstrated by this and other studies’ induced phenotypes such as “Learned Helplessness” and “Prenatally Restraint Stressed.”

Weren’t the researchers satisfied that the study confirmed what was known and made new findings? Why attempt to extend animal models that only treat effects to humans, as implied in the Introduction above and in the final sentence of the Discussion section:

“Future studies aimed at elucidating the specific roles of these regions in the pathophysiology of depression as well as serve as neural circuit-based targets for the development of novel therapeutics.”

http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fncir.2016.00003/full “Whole-Brain Mapping of Neuronal Activity in the Learned Helplessness Model of Depression” (Thanks to A Paper a Day Keeps the Scientist Okay)