It’s dawned on me that although links in blog posts are indexed by search engines, links in comments may not be. Here’s a post to elevate links in three comments that may have escaped notice.
From A review of biological variability:
“It is my view that all researchers have a narrow focus on what they want to research, without having an over-riding paradigm in which to fit the research and its results. Janovian Primal Therapy and theory, with its focus and understanding of the three different levels of consciousness would provide for a much needed over-arching paradigm, especially in the area of mental health.”
Congratulations on an excellent podcast, Gil!
59. Gilbert Bates in “Feel It Still” // Love, Primal Therapy & the Three Levels of Consciousness
From Remembering Dr. Arthur Janov:
“You are right on. The Norcross survey, in particular, is utter crap. More than half of those “experts” surveyed were CBT therapists who knew nothing about PT and yet deemed themselves confident to judge “primal scream therapy” as “discredited.” I feel the therapy will never be understood for what it is.”
Thanks for the detailed explanation, Bruce!
The Worst Comparative Psychotherapy Study Ever Published
From How one person’s paradigms regarding stress and epigenetics impedes relevant research:
“There is of course, reversibility. Michael Meaney’s baby rats had their epigenetic changes reversed with loving maternal care. There are several compounds in development which have been shown to reverse methylation. This former physician and researcher says, “Epigenetic changes affect the level of activity of our genes. Genetic activity levels affect our emotions, beliefs, and our bodies. Exploring epigenetics and chronic illness may help us understand causes that many of us suspect have played a role in the onset and evolution of our illnesses. Furthermore, these epigenetic changes have been found to be reversible, at least some of the time, even with a seemingly indirect treatment such as psychotherapy.” Epigenetics and Chronic Illness: Why Symptoms May Be Reversible
I looked up the psychotherapy references and found this: Serotonin tranporter methylation and response to cognitive behaviour therapy in children with anxiety disorders (reversible even with CBT, the weakest therapy of all!)
MAOA gene hypomethylation in panic disorder—reversibility of an epigenetic risk pattern by psychotherapy (also CBT)
So what gives? I suspect that your researcher is working with his/her head in the sand, hamstrung by their ideological biases. If CBT can effect epigenetic changes, imagine what primal therapy can do.”
And a seven-year anniversary repost of events that affect me every day:
One thought on “Unindexed comment links?”
The essence of science is: the mind doing a “mind trip” to get an explanation, then from that explanation to see if it can lead to some resolution. Then from that resolution to do another mind bending ‘trip-‘ to see if we can make use of it. Invariably to explain things in a manner that we can grasp what is being studied.
In other word the mind is symbolically “trying to disappear up it’s own ass hole”.
We were blessed, as a creature, to feel and express that feeling appropriately, and we had this facility from birth and perhaps before, as a fetus.
So what we have done is turned the whole of our being outside in … when there was no need to go there in the first place. Our feelings, if we will just allow them to freely express themselves, without “acting them out” will tell us all we need to know … not what we THINK we ought to know. Therein is the rub.